Latin America Advisor

Energy Advisor

A Publication of The Dialogue

What’s Behind the Energy Deal Scandal Sweeping Paraguay?

The governments of Paraguayan President Mario Abdo Benítez and Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro (L-R) signed a secret deal in May that has sparked controversy since it went public. // File Photo: Brazilian Government.

Paraguayan Foreign Minister Luis Castiglioni and other officials, including the head of state power company ANDE, resigned last month amid a public outcry over the signing of an energy deal with Brazil in relation to Itaipú—one of the world’s largest hydropower plants, which the countries jointly manage. Paraguayan lawmakers and officials said the secret deal would be detrimental to Paraguay and cost the country some $200 million. Following the scandal, the two countries scrapped the deal. What is at the heart of the controversy, and what effects will it have on Paraguayan President Mario Abdo Benítez’s agenda? What did the energy deal consist of, and was it indeed unfavorable to Paraguay? How important is Itaipú for each country, and should Brazil and Paraguay work to integrate their power sectors more? To what extent does hydropower dominate Paraguay’s energy mix, and should it look toward diversifying it with other sources of power?

Ricardo Canese, president of the hydroelectric commission for Parlasur and general coordinator of the Commission of Binational Hydroelectric Entities (CEBH): “The fundamental issue is who appropriates Paraguay’s energy from Itaipú. According to the Itaipú treaty, 50 percent of energy generated is Paraguayan, which covers cheap energy of $6/megawatt-hour (MWh) and expensive (guaranteed) energy of $44/MWh. Paraguay’s position has always been to demand half of the cheap energy and export the rest to Brazil. This is what Bolsonaro is questioning, going against the treaty and agreements in 2002, 2007 and 2009. The Bolsonaro/Abdo pact is unfavorable to Paraguay, and it violates the Itaipú treaty, because it establishes that between 89 percent (in 2019) and 84 percent (in 2022) of Itaipú’s cheap energy will go to Brazil, which amounts to a loss of $200 million for Paraguay. It also delivers the very valuable reservoir energy (50 percent Paraguayan) in the same proportion to Brazil, without any benefits. As for the power-contracting schedule…”

Read More

Top News




Complete editions of the Energy Advisor are delivered weekly to members of the Dialogue's Corporate Program and other subscribers. Sign up below for a free complimentary preview subscription.

Free Preview


About the Energy Advisor

A sister publication of the Inter-American Dialogue’s daily Latin America Advisor, the weekly Energy Advisor captures fresh analysis from business leaders and government officials on the most important developments in oil and gas, biofuels, the power sector, renewable energies, new technologies, and the policy debates shaping the future of energy in the Western Hemisphere. To subscribe or for more information, contact Erik Brand, publisher of the Advisor, at ebrand@thedialogue.org.


Subscribers See all


Staff

Erik Brand

Publisher
P. 612.242.1863
E. ebrand@thedialogue.org

Gene Kuleta

Editor
P. 202.463.2920
E. gkuleta@thedialogue.org

Anastasia Chacón González

Reporter
P. 202.463.2562
E. achacon@thedialogue.org